The 14th century philosopher and theologian William Ockham posed the now famous theory that, and I’m paraphrasing here, the simplest answer is probably the correct answer. This theory can also apply to those conducting genealogy research: if you are jumping through hoops trying to force a relationship between people, it probably isn’t there. Minimally, you are trying to establish a connection the wrong way.
This happens most frequently when people are trying to prove a connection to pilgrims, Mayflower descendants, presidents, people born before the year 1000 A.D., or royalty. I understand the need to feel connected to people and events that happened long ago in history, but folks, you are alive today. Isn’t that connection enough? Your family members are survivors who withstood barbaric practices, medieval torture, plagues, massacres, the guillotine, sailing into uncharted territories, the great depression, and the COVID-19 pandemic.
If you still feel compelled to call a famous person or historical figure Grandma or Pop Pop, use the theory of Ockham’s razor to help you focus on real connections. If you are working to find a long lost, previously unknown child that George Washington may have had with an undisclosed mistress, you are probably on a mission that won’t end well.
Prove what you can. Follow the lines of those in your family who came before you, wherever that journey may lead. Be surprised. Focus on giving previously unknown ancestors the attention they deserve. Find your own personal heroes. After all, these people are the reason you are alive today.
No Bull Genealogy 